After interviewing Seth Godin last week, I had the incredible opportunity to hear, for the second time, Malcolm Gladwell speak at a conference. He was keynote speaker on the second day of the 2009 Yellow Pages Association conference. His insights were, again, spot on, right in the current zeitgeist. Through amazing story-telling talent, he managed to explain at a high-level what was the main opportunity for the Yellow Pages industry.
Through the story of David Sarnoff, a RCA employee in the 1920’s, Gladwell showed us that, when it comes to business building, we often exaggerate the kind of resources needed. RCA were trying to sell radio sets and were struggling to do it. Sarnoff had the crazy idea (at the time) of doing a live broadcast of a major boxing event on radio. After saying “no” multiple times (thinking it was the stupidest idea they had ever heard), the RCA exec team finally told him he could do it but they would not provide him with any money or resources. Sarnoff managed to find everything he needed going as far as stealing a radio transmitter from the army and getting a friend to do play-by-play description to execute his plan. He also called RCA’s sales reps and told them to put radios everywhere people were hanging out on Friday nights. It became the tipping point for radio. In the following weeks, people lined up to buy radio sets. The executives at RCA had said no because the idea was too trivial, thinking that fixing the radio sales problem would require a lot of efforts. They were wrong.
He also talked about the importance of “re-framing”. That boxing match re-framed the use of radio in the minds of people. People associated radio with “news” but news was already readily available from the many newspapers published at the time. The radio set wasn’t about “news”, it was about bringing the world live in your living room. Gladwell also discussed the importance of re-framing when trying to bring about social change by talking about seatbelt usage. In the 80’s, even with many educational campaigns and restrictive laws, seatbelt usage was still low in the US. The frame was all wrong. The government was telling people what to do and we all know that doesn’t work well with American population. They decided to switch the focus to kids by saying that, if you have a child, he/she should be restrained. Within 3 years, seatbelt usage went up. Why? Those kids became advocate. It became a question of family responsibility. He also talked about the iPod. Was it the first MP3 player? or the best MP3 player? No! but why did it become the most successful? It re-framed the product from “technology gadget” to “fashion accessory” (simple and fashionable).
The New Yorker magazine writer then talked about “connectors”, those rare people that have large social circles. In experiments Gladwell did, he found out that most people have 30 people in their social circle. But in every group, there’s always one or two individuals who have 100, 200, or even 300 connections. These people have social powers, “a combination of attributes and personality that allows them to be connected to more people than the rest of us. · They have a greater diversity of connections in their life.” For most people, family, school, and work are the three usual social worlds. Connectors belong to 20 social worlds, often different social worlds from their own and this gives them social power. Gladwell added that the role of connector can be played by individuals or corporations and that it is fundamental today because we are more and more isolated. We function in silos because of the complexity of our modern life.
He finally discussed with us the concept of “Mavens”, trusted guides in a world of multiplied choices. Mavens are people/institutions that have an in-depth knowledge of specific topics and we turn to them for advice. You go in an electronics store, you see 75 laptops on one table and the only difference between each of them is a small sign with technical info and price. How do you decide which one to buy? You could ask a sales clerk but you can’t find them (or they’re not knowledgeable enough). You could educate yourself but it takes time, and you don’t have time. You end up asking people you know, people in your social circle, or sources you trust (maybe Consumer Reports). And they’ll tell you what to buy. People are happy if “someone has made the choice for me”. Someone has filtered and organized the information. That’s the “Maven”.
As for the Yellow Pages industry, Gladwell had this advice: “your frame is “we buy from the people we trust. It’s the thing that differentiates you from other players. (…) Yellow Pages are connectors. You bring customers together with small businesses. If you can capitalize on that, you’ll become more important. (…) and Yellow Pages are Mavens. You need to capitalize on that “Maven-ness”. The consumer needs what you have to offer “.
In the Q&A session, someone asked an excellent question about Google and their dominant position in the market. Gladwell doesn’t think Google’s position is that solid. As he said, “people buy from people they trust. That’s the frame. Google doesn’t have trust. Barriers to entry are low and a search engine is dumb. It’s no so good at understanding the human element. It’s the main difference between Google and Yellow Pages and you need to accentuate that difference”.
What it means: Malcolm Gladwell through his connectors and Mavens concepts told the assembled crowd that the future will consist of connections, influencers, conversations and filters. If you read between the lines, it’s the definition of social media and, as I’ve said before, social media is a game changer in local search. It’s the way you connect consumers to mavens and then to places. I believe this is the next big evolution in the Yellow Pages industry (and even the newspaper industry!) and it will change the way local media work forever. On a personal level, I was really inspired by Gladwell. As I often have “crazy” business ideas which turn into real, tangible success stories, I felt encouraged to continue pushing the envelope. And for me, that envelope is in the meeting of local and social media.
10 thoughts on “Malcolm Gladwell: "Re-Framing" the Yellow Pages Industry”
Thanks Sebastien…I couldn’t attend attend this event, for medical reasons, but thanks to you I got the main message…and I agree, and this is why I strongly believe in the success of http://www.answers.yellowpages.ca, a solution that my company, Yellow Pages group developped with Praized Media (Full disclosure)…this along with our yellowpages facebook app, our new presence on Twitter (seems that you got the scoop there), with yellowpages_ca are avenues that we are exploring and will benefit to our advertisers….I have to admit that my best bet is on answers.yellowpages.ca….
Gladwell was a highlight of the conference for myself as well. A couple of vendors IYP offerings came to mind when Gladwell spoke of reframing. He expressed some great thoughts for us to ponder in terms of reframing how people think of the yellow pages. We have all the tools to get a good start, just need to allow for more creativity in implementing those outside of the box ideas.
ps @ Jean-Pascal Lion: congrats on your (several) YellowPages.ca accolades won at the conference.
Another great post Sebastien – and congratulations to both Praized and YPG on the new answer service – a great example of social and local meeting.
Here’s a something else I think needs to be re-framed: we should be thinking of measurement as tracking rather than research. That is, every print ad should have tracking numbers and tracking URL’s.
Why? Because it strengthens the role of the Yellow Page publisher as maven. It puts them in a position to provide proof and insight to advertisers on a whole new scale.
And that tracking data can be analyzed to augment the social interactions by providing more comprehensive and insightful recommendations. It’s a potential goldmine.
@Eric I completely agree with the “proving ROI”. Google has changed the game when they introduced the pay-per-click with a transparent ROI model. Directory publishers are all about calls, so naturally, they should be tracking calls (and eventually moving to pay-per-call). I had the chance to sit down with Bill Dinan from Telmetrics to discuss call-tracking. I have a blog post coming up about that meeting.
“Google dominant position” Google domine Yelp ?
“search engine is dumb” mais y’a Google Maps aussi, qui est pas génial non plus mais quand même. Personnellement je m’en sers quand je cherche l’emplacement d’une chaîne du genre Home Depot (et si un coupon apparaissait je cliquerais probablement et achèterais qqchose que j’avais pas prévu).
Great Post Seb,
“Wheels are spinning in my head”…Wolley ring a bell 🙂
Congrats on the accolades and look forward to catching up soon.
Interesting post. It interesting that Malcolm Gladwell sees Yellow Pages as the Maven over Google. Not sure about that.
Nonetheless, I do think a combination of social + real time search + mobile technology can maybe create the new local space. It will be consumers that decide where and how they want to consume their info. Should be interesting to see how this plays out. My guess it will eventually all revolve around our mobile phones. In the meantime, Google (SEO & PPC) and Google Maps is where I’d invest my money if I was a SMB. Still one of the strongest ROI’s available today to a Small Business.